Once I figured out that I had to start the scenario in the editor & play-test it as Player 1, it was just fine. I played only once, at the hard level.
Balanced just fine. If you don't react quickly at the start you lose right away. Make the right moves & you live to fight again with a stronger force.
I thought the total scenario, including the map & story, was very creative; different from most.
Map Design: 4
Hardly any story, but is one really necesssary? Who doesn't know about Valley Forge? The instructions were clear, so I never doubted what had to be done (when I was strong enough to do it!)