|
Author |
File Description |
Pirate Hunter (id: pirate hunter) |
Posted on 12/17/08 @ 04:14 PM
File Details |
Game Version: |
TWC |
removed |
Pages: « First « 1 2 3 [4] | Author | Comments ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only ) |
---|
MrMario |
Posted on 02/20/09 @ 06:36 PM
Its been removed so why do you care sooooo much?[Edited on 02/20/09 @ 06:36 PM]
|
Mister SCP
Staff |
Posted on 02/21/09 @ 02:11 AM
because he write it before pirate removed the scenario. Anyway Teutonic is totally correct.
I think the scenario contest take a big influence of reviewer[Edited on 02/21/09 @ 02:14 AM]
|
Teutonic Twit |
Posted on 02/22/09 @ 12:51 AM
Big thanks Mister SCP
for your insight here...perhaps if MrMario and Commanderbly had been a little more diligent in reviewing Pirate Hunter's scenario, he may not have pulled it (sorry he felt compelled to do so). I wished he would have challenged both the reviews, but he chose not to, too bad.
AS you state, Mister SCP, I wrote my comments to them both, prior to the scenario being pulled. Had they stepped up and revised their blatantly inappropriate, off the standards reviews, maybe the scenario wouldn't have been pulled. Didn't happen.
So MrMario, the reason I care is inappropriate and incorrect evaluations of scenarios, as yours, are driving, young, new builders away.
I hope you feel quite proud of your accomplishment.
[Edited on 02/22/09 @ 01:01 AM]
|
Teutonic Twit |
Posted on 02/22/09 @ 01:07 AM
You know, after thinking about this, the failing of some reviewers to following the standards and correct blatant inaccuracies, I'm going to go back and re-edit my review, let's see what happens...
Mister SCP may I suggest you do the same... no rewrite, just revise the final score of each category ...[Edited on 02/22/09 @ 01:12 AM]
|
Mister SCP
Staff |
Posted on 02/22/09 @ 06:44 AM
So MrMario, the reason I care is inappropriate and incorrect evaluations of scenarios, as yours, are driving, young, new builders away.
I hope you feel quite proud of your accomplishment.
Thats the big problem of our community. Everyone wish that our number of scenario designer grow but if they publish there scenarios dumb reviews and negativ comments dissapoint scenario designers and often causes conflicts
You know, after thinking about this, the failing of some reviewers to following the standards and correct blatant inaccuracies, I'm going to go back and re-edit my review, let's see what happens...
Mister SCP may I suggest you do the same... no rewrite, just revise the final score of each category ...
Yes I do maybe we have succes.
|
MrMario |
Posted on 02/22/09 @ 01:05 PM
So it was a bad review sorry.
But not take it all out on me. |
Teutonic Twit |
Posted on 03/04/09 @ 06:36 PM
MrMario,
Thank you for re-evaluating this scenario and modifying your rating. This should encourage new designers to keep developing scenarios to add to the HG files. Thanks again... |
Pages: « First « 1 2 3 [4] |
HGDL v0.8.2 |
Rating |
---|
3.9 | Breakdown |
---|
Playability | 4.0 | Balance | 3.6 | Creativity | 3.9 | Map Design | 4.0 | Story/Instructions | 4.1 |
Statistics |
Downloads: | 1,583 |
Favorites: [] | 0 |
Size: | 9.01 MB |
Added: | 12/17/08 |
|