Playability: 2
The problem with Playability and Map Design is that when I take the 5 wagons and bring them to the French or take the Buffalo and Bring it to the Indians, nothing changes. There is no alliance announced like it's supposed to in the instructions.
Balance: 5
Great balance, since it was a challenge to take over the enemy fort, but it didn't attack your base much either.
Creativity: 5
Very creative.
Map Design: 2
The problem with Playability and Map Design is that when I take the 5 wagons and bring them to the French or take the Buffalo and Bring it to the Indians, nothing changes. There is no alliance announced like it's supposed to in the instructions.
Story/Instructions: 4
It should give better explanations about how to complete the secondary objectives, because they didn't work.