Playability: 3
The game works, no major concerns there but nothing exceptional.
Balance: 2
Settlers always win, way too powerful and the Janissary units are way to weak
Creativity: 3
Been done before, no exceptional features.
Map Design: 3
Very little to map design.
Story/Instructions: 3
Simple enough instructions to understand.
Additional Comments:
Settlers way to strong, maybe allow them to build towers and walls and power up the Janissary units to balance the game. Strategy is all but null since there are no extra features besides running to use. Even putting up gates only settlers could pass through (or vice versa) to sort of balance the game.