Well, just shared this on ESO yesterday and now is one of the most played maps there, here is my review.
(Insert Playability analysis here)
Awesome gameplay, the coop part of the map is just epic, had a lot of fun with the numerous matches I had.
(Insert Balance analysis here)
Probably this ruined the map, it's not impossible, but takes a lot of time, and people start leaving and I've never completed this map, I tried to add 1 extra villager to each one and the time to get all the perks reduces to half an hour so maybe a fourth villager could do it. Almost no one stays in a 3 hour match.
(Insert Creativity analysis here)
I maybe have seen similar maps but this one is by far the best, the idea in general is great but as I said in Balance, it kind of ruins that.
Map Design: 4
(Insert Map Design analysis here)
Nice map design, it's a 4 because of that enemy units spreading out in the top half of the map.
(Insert Story/Instructions analysis here)
Easy to follow, players get the basics very early.
Additional Comments: A map with a lot of potential that could be one of the best maps in AOE3, with some balance and other fixes.